Supreme Court, blogosphere, scandalsNovember 16, 2005 3:27 pm

Ms. Article III Groupie was outed and found to be a “Him” and a federal prosecutor. Oh, the shame of it all! He was outed by Jeffrey Toobin of “The New Yorker”:

In real life, A3G is a thirty-year-old Newark-based assistant U.S. attorney named David Lat. “The blog really reflects two aspects of my personality,” he said over lunch recently. “I am very interested in serious legal issues as well as in fun and frivolous and gossipy issues. I can go from the Harvard Law Review to Us Weekly very quickly.” Lat, who has a boyish face, lives in Manhattan and commutes to New Jersey, and he writes his blog entries in his spare time. Like A3G, he graduated from Harvard College and Yale Law School, and he worked briefly at a big New York law firm. Although his current job as a prosecutor has required him to pare back his life style, he says, “I still hoard toiletries from luxury hotels all over the world.” Lat interviewed for a Supreme Court clerkship, with Justice Antonin Scalia, but he didn’t get it.

“Yale treats certain judges like celebrities,” he said. “And I’ve always had a certain status anxiety about not having clerked on the Supreme Court.” (A3G often refers to Supreme Court clerks as “the Elect.”) “My interest in celebrity has kind of metastasized from the judges to the clerks,” he added.

Too bad for A3G that she (or he) did not read Kerfuffles’ posts about “Blogging For Dissidents” and “Blogging Anonymously”.

Underneath Their Robes - Blog Search

“Underneath Their Robes” cached.

Supreme Court, courts, abortion, WaPoNovember 15, 2005 6:45 pm

Oh the shocking news that has just been revealed by WaPo et al! A document released Monday shows that in 1985, Samuel Alito wrote to the Reagan administration that he was particularly proud to help argue that “the Constitution does not protect a right to an abortion.” What does it portend for the survival of the republic? Well, the good news is that it proves that Samuel Alito has actually read the Constitution.

Alito also wrote in the document that he believed “very strongly in limited government, federalism, free enterprise, the supremacy of the elected branches of government, the need for a strong defense and effective law enforcement and the legitimacy of a government role in protecting traditional values.” ~~The Washington Post

A real bomb-thrower, isn’t he?

Kerfuffles, Supreme Court, courts, blogosphere, United StatesOctober 31, 2005 1:11 pm

When we tintinnabulate the praises of Judge Samuel A. Alito’s nomination to the U.S. Supreme Court, we will be rooting for one of our own commenters here at Kerfuffles! Check out this from Judge Alito: Comment to Kerfuffles.

Thanks for the shout out! I’m so glad to know that people didn’t stop caring when Harriet went down in flames.

Comment by Samuel Alito — October 31, 2005 @ 12:35 pm |

“Outside the Beltway” describes the nominee as “Modest, Brilliant and Nice” and links to WaPo’s “As Democrats Lead Opposition, GOP Moderates May Control Vote”. Another informative WaPo piece on Samuel Alito is “Alito Leans Right Where O’Connor Swung Left“, by Charles Lane, of WaPo.

I think that Judge Alito is going to need all the cheerleading that we can assemble for him, as according to WizBag’s post today, “Alito Smear Document Came Directly From DNC“:

If you’re attempting to mount a sleazy smear campaign against Supreme Court nominee Samuel Alito inferring that he is in some way in bed with the mob, it’s probably best not to electronically sign your name to it. As … one of Howard Dean’s little loose cannons at the DNC (Chris Pendergrast) is responsible for this little piece of slime…

Supreme Court, courts, Democrats, liberals, humor, satire, United States, Harry Reid 12:15 pm

Leaders of the Moonbats, Batman Chuckie and Harry Robin, are expected to try and save the Republic from the likes of Judge Samuel A. Alito.
Chuckie and Harry

However, “The Right Honorable Samuel A. Alito, Jr.” (the “A” stands for awesome) writes - never fear, for he is one “Super Man” and his daughter has already armed him with “Kryptonite, which apparently is a song by a band called Coldplay“. Judge “Superman” Alito is ready for the battle against Moonbat Jokers, Riddlers, Teddy the Penguin, and Boxer the Catwoman.

From WaPo: President Bush Announces Alito Nomination
Bush Selects Alito for Supreme Court
Good SCOTUS Stuff from VodkaPundit

Supreme Court, courts, George Bush, news, United States 10:44 am

Supreme Court Picks from the Bloggers or - How NOT to Win a Nomination for SCOTUS!

Which blogger would you choose for SCOTUS if you were POTUS? Would you confirm this blogger - J. Michael Luttig - who blogged “The President of the United States just proved beyond a shadow of an unreasonable doubt that he’s the most moronic organism in the history of life on earth“? Or would you nominate the other SCOTUS-Blogger-in-the-Running, The Right Honorable Samuel A. Alito, Jr., who asked this about the SCOTUS-Blogger-in-the-Running who called you an “I.D.I.O.T” of lower intelligence than a “manual laborer“: (Hint, Hint - It’s a no-brainer!)

(from the blog of The Right Honorable Samuel A. Alito, Jr.)
Would you confirm this man?

J. Michael Luttig

posted by SamuelAlito

(from the blog of J. Michael Luttig - Luttig’s Lair)
Monday, October 03, 2005
HAIRY-ETTE: ALL EYELINER, NO JURISPRUDENCE

Every hour that goes by, the more depressed I get. It’s not that I’m mad about not being appointed to the Supreme Court. (I mean, I am, but this is much bigger than that.) It’s that the President of the United States, whom at this point I wouldn’t allow one of my clerks to hire as a manual laborer, had to choose such a sycophantic lightweight to fill what would have been my seat. The only possible distinction that Hairy-Ette might hold is she’s the first Supreme Court nominee whose eyeliner is thicker than her curriculum vitae.

posted by J. Michael Luttig @ 12:04 PM 13 comments
THICK MAKEUP, THIN SKIN

Memo to Hairyette: if you can’t take the heat, get your ass back in the kitchen.

posted by J. Michael Luttig @ 10:16 AM 0 comments
WORST NOMINEE EVER

Harriet the (small) Fry
Harriet Yesman
Harryreid Miers
Harriet Lamerz

posted by J. Michael Luttig @ 9:05 AM 0 comments
LEMME SPELL IT OUT FOR YOU: I.D.I.O.T.

The President of the United States just proved beyond a shadow of an unreasonable doubt that he’s the most moronic organism in the history of life on earth.

posted by J. Michael Luttig @ 9:03 AM

Apparently Judge Luttig must have believed that Harriet Miers was a “shoo-in“. HA! The joke’s on him!

Luttig was mentioned frequently as being near the top of G. W. Bush’s list of potential nominees to the Supreme Court of the United States to replace retiring Justice Sandra Day O’Connor. However, Bush first decided to nominate John G. Roberts (who later was renominated for the Chief Justice position), and then nominated Harriet Miers. When the Miers nomination was withdrawn on October 27, 2005, speculation regarding a Luttig nomination was refueled. However, President Bush instead chose to nominate Samuel Alito. (Wikipedia)

From WaPo: Campaign for the Supreme Court
Bush, Alito Text and Comments

Kerfuffles, Supreme Court, courts, George Bush, blogosphere, United StatesOctober 12, 2005 9:46 am

Mind-bloggling over Harriet Miers!

He’s fighting a war on two fronts; abroad in the Middle East and here in Washington with the Dems. He’s dealing with the ravishes of nature’s fury in the Southland. He was even trying to fix Society Security for future generations. Now there are whiffs of mutiny in the air. The Captain Bligh Bloggers are after his hide. Can’t we just give the guy some slack? Can’t we at least wait until the Senate confirmation hearings are finished to trash him and his new Supreme Court nominee? Can’t we trust him to be President and to make the big decisions? NO - say the Big Bloggers! Why? Because the “Big MSM Pundits” George Will and Bill Crystal and Charles Krauthammer and John Fund say that President Bush picked his nominee without consulting with them first, that’s why!

Kerfuffles agrees with Don Surber’s great post about President George W. Bush and his pick for the Supreme Court, Harriet Miers. Cao’s Blog agrees with us too. After all, according to WaPo’s profile of her HERE, the fact that she has a degree in mathematics indicates to Kerfuffles that she is not your “run of the mill” lady lawyer. She is apt to have an analytical mind which probably would contribute new insight to the Supremes.

In fact, Kerfuffles did a wee bit of research of some brief biographies of the Supremes and was pleasantly surprised to find that Ms. Miers could indeed be a breath of fresh air to that elite brotherhood. Ms. Miers did NOT receive her degrees from Harvard, Yale, Stanford, Oxford, Columbia or Northwestern as have all of the other Supremes, including Rhenquist and O’Connor. She is a true Southerner - not only born and bred, as was Clarence Thomas, but she stayed in Dixie and got her education there too. If nothing else, that should be a clincher! Not one of the Supremes has any evidence of advanced education in the physical sciences. Ms. Miers, with her degree in mathematics, would be a stand-out in that regard.

The career path of Ms. Miers has been quite a different one from that of any of the current justices. She has been an elected president and a co-managing partner of large law firms. She is a successful trial litigator representing big American corporations. She has been involved in both state and local politics in Texas and was elected to the Dallas City Council. She worked as a volunteer on the Texas Lottery Commission when it was mired in scandal and was instrumental in its cleanup. She has worked inside the White House as an influential confident of an American President. These experiences are quite at variance with those of the current appointed Supremes and bode well for her being an enrichment to them.

BelderBlog has made a search for her records, posted snippets, and commented upon them (others here), sarcastically concluding:

After all, Harriet Miers is just a “third-rate lawyer” from “an undistinguished law firm” who’s never handled any big cases, hasn’t got any appellate experience to speak of, and has never, ever done anything involving really hard or important stuff like constitutional law. She’s just an unqualified crony. Fetches Dubya’s coffee. There’s just nothing in her record, no meaningful achievements, to distinguish her from a million other lawyers in the country.

Everyone says so. I read it today in the Washington Post! So it must be true, huh?

Chris Cillizza at “The Fix” is awaiting condemnation from Republican senators. Is it forthcoming? If so, he suspects it could come from Senator Sam Brownback who is a possible presidential candidate and a member of the Senate Judiciary Committee. Brownback recently complained: “A lot of us wanted to see somebody that was a well-formed jurist so that they had a track record of what they would do in cases coming in front of the court. Harriet Miers doesn’t have that track record and doesn’t seem to be well-formed in her judicial philosophy, having never been on the bench.” Kerfuffles advises not to bet big bucks on any Republicans voting against the President’s choice, especially Brownback.

Chris is saying in “RNC Tries to Rally Bloggers Behind Miers” that Republican National Committee Chairman Ken Mehlman held a conference call today with some conservative bloggers attempting to garner blog support for Harriet Miers. Blogger Patrick Ruffini organized the event as he is now directing online operations for the RNC. Mehlman told the pro-Republicans that Harriet Mier would not hang about wanting “to curry favor with the Georgetown cocktail set.” Cool! Is that what David Souter does?

Tracked at Big Bloggers Patterico’s Pontifications , Outside the Beltway, RedState.org’s ConfirmThem, and Michelle Malkin who wishes the President had nominated blogger, radio pundit Laura Ingraham instead.

Kerfuffles, Supreme Court, courtsOctober 4, 2005 11:13 am

Coalition of the Chillin’
Patrick Ruffini, one of the few conservatives who believes that Harriet Miers is one also, is starting the “Coalition of the Chillin’”, Part Deux. Patrick’s not worried, so why should the rest of us fret? Join in and find out.

Supreme Court, courts 10:30 am

Harry and Harriet
Harry Reid + Harriet Miers = Smooth Sailing for “W
Remember yesterday that Kerfuffles told you in “Smooth Sailing” that Harriet Miers had been the “pick” of Big Dem - Senator Harry Reid? Well lookey here at the LA Times today:

Indeed, Miers was among the top White House aides who were vetting potential candidates for the court, and her name was put forward by an unusual source — the leader of the Senate Democrats, Harry Reid of Nevada.

On Sept. 21, during a breakfast meeting with Bush and other senators, Reid suggested that Miers would make a good nominee, citing his favorable impression of her during the confirmation process for the new chief justice, John G. Roberts Jr.

Why even WaPo allludes to the same:

Based on advance soundings with Senate Democratic leader Harry M. Reid (Nev.) and conservative leader James C. Dobson, the White House calculated that Miers would draw broad support.

Tracked at JackLewis.net and The Political Teen.

Kerfuffles, Supreme Court, courtsOctober 3, 2005 6:32 pm

For El Presidente this time around!

Most of the Dems love this nominee! Senators Harry Reid and Charles Schumer think she’s tops. In fact, she was picked by Harry Reid. Remember back in early July, he urged the President to moderate his choice for the Supreme Court so that the Democrats would be willing to support the nomination, saying that they did not want any more judges on the Supreme Court? Snarling Bob Beckel thinks she’s a great choice too. Perhaps she was even recommended by Chief Justice John Roberts. Who knows?

I do know that The Big Byrd from West Virginia had his hands a-stirrin’ the pudding. I blogged about it on July 13th.

Warned y’all I did! Yes, indeedy. I warned you that Senator Harry Reid and the “Gang of 14″ were plotting to pick the new Supreme Court justice to replace Justice O’Conner. I hope that my prediction is wrong, but look what’s a happening just today according to The Hill: “Bush telephoned Byrd — … yesterday to solicit his views. ‘I’m praising the president for listening, for reaching out,’ Byrd, among the administration’s harshest congressional critics, told The Hill. He said he had received a call earlier from former Sen. Fred Thompson (R-Tenn.), who is helping Bush select a nominee and get him or her confirmed, and from White House counsel Harriet Myers. Byrd said he forwarded two names to the White House.

Now we know who the “other of the two names” was! Ms. Harriet Miers! Of course, the first of the two names was his own - Senator Bobby Byrd of West Virginny. El Presidente passed over the Old Byrd - probably thinking he was too old for the job.

The only conservative I have found who is pleased with the president’s pick is Patrick Ruffini. He says “I’m going to state categorically that conservatism is sitting pretty at this hour. That’s because Harry Reid has just been hosed - and he doesn’t even know it. … The Court will almost certainly move to the right as a result of the nomination and confirmation of Harriet Miers.” Oh yes, and that commentator on Fox News likes her too - can’t remember his name right now (Fred Barnes - it came to me). Ruffini also claims that Harriet Miers is conservative, so that makes two who are vouching for her, plus El Presidente.

Kerfuffles’ predictions were wrong, and that is a good thing, for whatever disappointments there be with Ms. Miers, she has to be a better choice than Hillary, John McCain or Senator Robert Byrd, which is who I suspected that Harry Reid had advised the President to choose.

Non-judges Only for the Supreme Court Said Harry Reid and Three of the Supremes! And El Presidente obeyed.

Kerfuffles, John Roberts, politics, news, blogosphere, blog, blogging, fashionOctober 2, 2005 5:22 pm

Dance, then, wherever you may be,
I am the Lord of the Dance, said He,
And I’ll lead you all, wherever you may be,
And I’ll lead you all in the dance, said He.

~~Sidney Carter, from Lord of the Dance

Jackie Roberts

I have gotten so many visitors to my old blog, “Kerfuffles the 1st”, looking to read my posts about little dancing Jack Roberts, that I am including the links here at my new blog. Jack or Jackie Roberts is the young son of the new Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, John Roberts.

What Makes Jackie Dance?

Dancing Boy Roberts

Pot Calls Kettle White

« Previous PageNext Page »